|High School:||The Tathall School|
Milby is one of many talented midfielders for the Bulldogs. She was a four-time all-state selection and MVP of the senior all-star game at The Tatnall School. She also played in the Delaware Olympic Development Program for seven years and was co-captain for the FC Delco Appaloosas Club, which won the Eastern Pennsylvania championship. In addition, she was a member of the under-19 Region I team.